I was somewhat taken aback the first time around when I saw the breaking news about the Agriprocessors Plant in Postville Iowa being raided by immigration officials. My first thought had been, why are they not doing the same at IBP? Why picking on the Kosher plant and not the Treif one?
Yesterday, while with a friend, we discussed libertarianism and the issue of human predation. How one needs to find a medium between the “Nanny State” and the “Laissez-faire’ extremes… in the following case – there should be no need for a Nanny State – Yirat Shamayim (Fear of Heaven) should suffice – or does it?
Today while at the gym, the New York Times lay in a basket waiting for my wandering eyes… there I read in a column on the left side with more recent developments concerning this particular case – Former workers allege 13 hour days… being overworked with sharp knives, unsafe conditions….It reminded of me of a friend who worked at a restaurant for 13 hours shifts and as well for a G-d fearing man…
- Agriprocessors moving fast to address the situation
- Change in Management at Agriprocessors
Note – I won’t honor Peta’s axe to grind – they are the same PETA that protested against Palestinians for using donkeys to carry explosives that would kill people. PETA-philes should have been born vegetables. End Note.
it donned on me that I had avoided commenting about this case, as I know the owners, and was always an object of their kindness. They employ over 800 people directly, have built a community around them (Non-Jewish as well, and have prospered). It pains me to read these allegations in the NYT, not because I do not believe they could be true – slaughterhouses seems to have these same recurring themes – but because it lends credence to those looking to vilify Jews because of the actions of a few misguided entrepreneurs. A friend of mine always stated – “If the business is not profitable legally, it is not a business” – here it holds true. Using illegal labor to lower operating costs is a widespread practice in Iowa, Georgia, Colorado and anywhere slaughterhouses hang their hat. To the point that immigration raids have affected the economies of many states – is it a coincidence that we have gone downwards in our “productivity” after the Bush administration started to crackdown and allow crackdowns on illegal immigrants? I digress – but in any case, the Agriprocessors case is one that hits home. It is not the first time this company has been in the news – there was concern in the past over their shechita as well (in 2004) – then effective April 15, 2008 KAJ (Kehillat Adath Jeshrun) or the “Washington Heights Heksher” pulled its supervision out owing to other issues there. Quoting a respected Rabbi: “If you ever have a doubt about kashrus, just look for the KAJ seal, no matter what hashkofa you hail from, they are to be trusted, even above our own!”.
My comments won’t be many more – except that If a person is going to use G-d as a partner, as the kosher businesses do, they would do well to go back and review the Chofetz Chayim’s works concerning Business Ethics and practices. Illegal aliens are humans too – and the halacha applies to “bein adam le chavero” – between a man and his neighbor, and this applies to each and every human. If the river is loud, it’s because it has rocks – scoff at Hebrew National’s kashruth, but how is your stuff even kosher?
Part of the appeal of kosher products is the elimination of pain in the slaughter process, (the animals toxins are not released into the flesh you will eat)) yet when human suffering is involved, how can you allege that the morsel you are eating is still kosher?